Manoj Muntashir Makes an Emotional Appeal: ‘Don’t Compare Ramayana to Adipurush’

Manoj Muntashir Makes an Emotional Appeal as anticipation for Nitesh Tiwari’s Ramayana continues to reach new heights across the country. With every new update about the film grabbing headlines, comparisons with the 2023 release Adipurush have once again become a hot topic among movie lovers. Addressing the ongoing debate, the celebrated lyricist and writer urged audiences to avoid comparing the two films, saying that every adaptation of the epic deserves to be judged on its own vision and storytelling.

His heartfelt request has quickly sparked discussions across social media platforms, where fans remain divided. While some agree that Ramayana should be evaluated only after its release, others believe comparisons are inevitable because both films are inspired by one of India’s greatest epics. Manoj Muntashir’s statement has not only reignited conversations about Adipurush but has also shifted attention to the immense expectations surrounding Nitesh Tiwari’s ambitious project.

As someone who closely follows Bollywood and the entertainment industry, I believe his appeal comes at the right time. Mythological films carry emotional and cultural significance for millions of people, making them far more than just another big-budget release. Audiences expect authenticity, powerful storytelling, and respect for the original source material. When those expectations aren’t met, the criticism can be intense—as seen with Adipurush, which faced backlash over its dialogues, visual effects, and creative choices despite its massive budget.

Now, with Ramayana bringing together a star-studded cast including Ranbir Kapoor, Sai Pallavi, and Yash under the direction of acclaimed filmmaker Nitesh Tiwari, expectations are higher than ever.

The film is already being described as one of the biggest cinematic projects in Indian cinema, with reports suggesting a budget of several hundred crores and world-class visual effects. Against this backdrop, Manoj Muntashir’s emotional appeal serves as a reminder that every filmmaker deserves the opportunity to tell a timeless story in their own way before audiences pass judgment.

In this article, let’s take a closer look at what Manoj Muntashir said, why his statement is making headlines, how fans are reacting, and whether Ramayana can create its own legacy without being overshadowed by comparisons to Adipurush.

Why Did Manoj Muntashir Request the People to Not Compare Ramayana with Adipurush 

As for Manoj Muntashir, he feels that every film maker should be allowed to show his take on Ramayana.

In a heartfelt case for his film, he stated readers have to judge the new film on its own merits and not come preloaded with baggage from previous adaptations. 

Why does he say this: Adipurush is still remembered for the controversy, dialogues, visual effects, and creative choices. Since the dialogues for Adipurush are written by Manoj Muntashir himself, he knows very well how serious criticism is as far as creators and audience expectations are concerned. 

He advocated that people should allow Ramayana to find an identity for itself instead of rehashing old debates. 

I think this is an acceptable ask. A movie is a living art, technology changes, and every filmmaker brings his unique perspective to the canvas. Having viewers run comparisons between projects that have yet to release often does little in the way of allowing them to approach a film with fresh eyes. 

As the dialogue writer of Adipurush, Manoj Muntashir found himself at the center of that criticism. Many of the film’s dialogues were heavily discussed online, with some becoming viral for the wrong reasons. The controversy highlighted how deeply audiences connect with stories like the Ramayana, where even small creative changes can trigger strong emotional reactions.

Having experienced that level of public scrutiny firsthand, Manoj understands better than most how challenging it is to adapt a revered epic while balancing modern filmmaking with audience expectations.

Perhaps that is why his recent statement carries more weight. Rather than reopening old wounds or revisiting the debates surrounding Adipurush, he wants the conversation to shift toward the future. He believes Ramayana should be allowed to establish its own identity and be evaluated solely on the quality of its storytelling, performances, direction, and overall execution.

Instead of entering theatres with preconceived opinions shaped by previous adaptations, he hopes audiences will watch the film with an open mind and decide for themselves whether it succeeds.

From my perspective, his appeal is both reasonable and timely. Comparisons are natural in cinema, especially when multiple films are inspired by the same legendary story.

However, judging a movie before its release often creates unnecessary bias. Every filmmaker brings a unique creative vision, every cast interprets characters differently, and filmmaking technology continues to evolve with each passing year. What worked—or failed—in one adaptation doesn’t necessarily determine the fate of another.

Nitesh Tiwari’s Ramayana is being developed with a different creative team, a different cast, and reportedly one of the biggest production budgets in Indian cinema. It deserves the opportunity to be appreciated for its own artistic choices rather than constantly being measured against Adipurush. Ultimately, audiences will have the final say, but that judgment should come after experiencing the film, not before it reaches the big screen.

Why Is Adipurush One of The Most Controversial Movies in Bollywood? 

Adipurush is based on the epic Ramayana (what else) and started life as one of the highest budget Indian films, with an estimated budget of ₹600 crore when it released in June 2023. The film, which was directed by Om Raut, featured Prabhas as the lead alongside Kriti Sanon and Saif Ali Khan. 

Expectations were sky-high before release. There were hopes of a mega-budget making, Ramayana adapted for the silver screen with high-quality VFX and state-of-the-art technology. 

Instead, the film drew much backlash. 

The major concerns were: 

• Dialogues which sounded very modern for so many viewers. 
• VFX that were built at sky-high cost & failed to live up to its expectations. 
• Character designs that divide audiences. 
• The problem is that most faithful adaptations of the epic were termed as unimaginative. 

Despite the film raking in hundreds of crores worldwide, audience reactions were a mix and online discourse around it continued long after over its theatrical run. 

The incident also turned out to be a lesson for Bollywood that translating sacred tales is not only about craft, but also the heart. 

What has pushed Ramayana to have such humongous expectations already 

In contrast to other potential Bollywood projects, Ramayana has been exciting audiences for years now. 

The upcoming film is a collaboration with acclaimed director Nitesh Tiwari and, as such, will likely have an excellent cast including: 

• Ranbir Kapoor as Lord Ram 
• Sai Pallavi as Goddess Sita 
• Yash as Ravana 
• Sunny Deol as Hanuman (reported) 
• Reports in the industry circles also suggest that, if true, this would be one of India’s biggest films as its budget may go over ₹800 crore. 

The wait is all the more enticing considering Nitesh Tiwari’s reputation. His past films have shown a healthy blend of good drama and box office charisma so fans can rest assured that Ramayana will combine spectacle with substance. 

The updates, ranging from the first-look visuals to casting announcements, all have got millions of views across social media platforms. 

Ramayana is not simply a film for many moviegoers; it is an event. 

Is Ramayana free from shadow of Adipurush? 

Which is probably the biggest question of this film today. 

By October of 2023 this audience will know what comparisons are whether they admit to acknowledging them or not. It is human instinct to compare two films inspired by the same epic. 

But Ramayana may etch its own legacy on the basis of a few reasons. 

Whereas, you have Adipurush Ramayana Feb 2023 Film Om Raut Nitesh Tiwari 6034506860+ crore Prabhas Ranbir Kapoor Mixed Higher 

Ramayana has the potential to change the course of mythological filmmaking in India if it stays true to its story and brings modern cinematic quality. 

• The Last Image: Ramayana Vs Adipurush 
• My Take: Each Epic Requires Its Own Character 
• I write about movies nearly every day, and I think many audiences pass judgement on films way too soon. 

Millions of comments within hours on trailers. Fan Wars start before shooting is even over. This is the path where expectations are unrealistic and conversations change from storytelling to social media conflict. 

That is why Manoj Muntashir’s statement struck a chord with me. 

While the reception to Adipurush may be a confusing spectacle, it bodes well for anything that comes next in the Ramayana. 

All filmmakers have a right to tell a story in their own voice. 

Every audience should be given an opportunity to see it without the baggage. 

Each adaptation ought to be able to stand (or fall) on its own. 

Conclusion

Manoj Muntashir’s emotional appeal has added a thoughtful perspective to the growing conversation around Ramayana. Instead of encouraging comparisons with Adipurush, he has asked audiences to give the upcoming film a fair chance and judge it on its own merits. Considering the scale of Nitesh Tiwari’s ambitious adaptation and the immense expectations surrounding it, his message highlights an important point—every retelling of an epic deserves to be viewed with an open mind.

As someone who closely follows Bollywood and entertainment news, I believe comparisons are inevitable, but they shouldn’t define a film before its release. Ramayana brings together a strong cast, a respected director, and what is reportedly one of the biggest budgets in Indian cinema. Whether it lives up to the hype will only be known once audiences experience it on the big screen.

For now, Manoj Muntashir’s statement has shifted the focus from controversy to conversation. Fans across social media continue to debate whether Ramayana can set a new benchmark for mythological films, but the final verdict will ultimately rest with the audience. Until then, excitement for one of Bollywood’s most anticipated releases continues to grow.

FAQs